laws.ru was the website "RUSSIAN LEGISLATION" ("РОССИЙСКОЕ ЗАКОНОДАТЕЛЬСТВО"), the web version of the "Kodeks" legal database maintained by the Nizhny Novgorod INFORIS Internet center, a state unitary enterprise with offices in the Nizhny Novgorod Kremlin[1]. The domain was registered on November 13, 1998[2], and the earliest surviving snapshot of the home page is dated November 22, 1999[3]. The database offered search across 44 thousand documents, and included a separate section on the legislation of Nizhny Novgorod Region[3]. Substantive copies of the home page end in June 2002; from 2004 onward, the address displayed a notice that the domain was for sale[4][5].

What Was on the Site

The home page advertised a "promptly updated database of Russian legislation, 'Kodeks,' containing over 44,000 documents in Russian and more than 1,000 in English"[3]. Search worked by issuing body, key phrase, words in a document's title or text, number, date range of adoption, and status; documents that had recently come into force or been amended could also be browsed separately[3]. Each document had a "status" field — in force, current version, no longer in force, repealed, amended[3].

The list of sections filled the entire home page: Russian legislation as a complete set of documents, legal regulation of business in Russia, templates of legal and business documents, an archive of Russian regulatory acts, an archive of Russian Federation documents from 1991–1992, and an archive of Russian Federation and USSR documents before 1991, international law, and the legislation of Moscow, Saint Petersburg, and the Leningrad and Nizhny Novgorod Regions[3]. The full texts of the Constitution, the codes, and international agreements and conventions were available free of charge[3].

The search itself did not live on this domain: the internal links of the 1999 version led to black.inforis.nnov.su/infobase/, that is, to a database server in the nnov.su domain, which greeted visitors with the line "Inforis Databases — Click here to enter Inforis Database Server"[3][6]. Some of the databases were also served on ports 8001–8006 of the same address as www.laws.ru[3][7]. The footer carried the Rambler's Top100 counters and those of madein.nnov.ru, a Nizhny Novgorod site, and the banner space was given over to the bizlink.ru network[3].

Whose database it was

What was developed in Nizhny Novgorod was not the database but its web version. The page "Legislation in the KODEKS IPS" on INFORIS's own site said so directly: "The databases were created and are maintained by the State Enterprise TsKR. The WWW version was developed by the company INFORIS"[8]. The State Enterprise TsKR is the St. Petersburg Computer Development Center, from which the Kodeks family of legal systems grew.

The same page stated that "from April 10, 1997, access to the KODEKS IPS will be on a paid basis"[8] — which means the web version was already running then, in the inforis.ru/laws/ section, and it acquired its own domain a year and a half later. The project's English-language storefront also initially stood on the provider's domain, under the heading "LAWS: KODEKS and INFOBASE. Data bases of Russian laws"[9].

The card index that INFORIS put on the web was considerably broader than what made it onto the laws.ru home page: economic, customs, banking, insurance, housing, social and labor, and criminal legislation, arbitration practice, intellectual property, forestry, construction and architecture, and, in the regional part, Novosibirsk, Perm, Tomsk, Tatarstan, and Murmansk Region alongside Moscow and St. Petersburg[8].

How much access cost

There were two kinds of fees. One was per kilobyte: 0.05 conventional units per kilobyte of Russian-language text and 0.24 per kilobyte of English. The other was monthly: 100 conventional units per month regardless of volume[10]. The exchange rate of the unit was published on the same page — in January 2000 it was 26.05 rubles[10]. An invoice was issued for no less than 10 conventional units and was valid for five banking days, and the user could issue it himself over the Internet; the original invoice, the tax invoice, and the certificate of completed work were sent by mail after the payment arrived[10][11].

Every new user was given a credit of 50 kilobytes — "$2.50" by the accounting of the time — so that they could "assess the convenience of use" and decide whether the database suited them[12]. Individuals were offered the option of printing out a payment slip and paying at any branch of Sberbank, then reporting the payment to the site[10].

Payments from abroad were accepted only on a monthly basis — $100 per month of unlimited access — and did not go to Russia. The English subscription page named the recipient as "Landowner Trading & Investments Ltd." with an account at Barrington Bank Inc. (St. John's, Antigua) via Saules Banka in Riga, and until April 28, 2000, via Tallinn Business Bank[13]; the 1999 version on the provider's website gave the same account via Bank of New York — Inter Maritime Bank in Geneva[9].

The Nizhny Novgorod part

The project had a twofold Nizhny Novgorod connection. First, in terms of content: "The Database also includes the legislation of Nizhny Novgorod Region" — a phrase that stood on the main page from 1999 and survived into the last substantive version, from 2002[3][4]. Second, a commercial one: "for ip-clients of the INFORIS Internet Center, full access to the 'Nizhny Novgorod Legislation' database is provided free of charge"[10] — the local provider gave its own subscribers the regional part for nothing.

The "Agreement No. … on the Provision of Information Services" posted on the site named as the provider the State Unitary Enterprise "Territorial Center of Informatization of the Administration of Nizhny Novgorod Region," represented by its director, Mikhail Markovich Konikov[14]. Under the agreement, the server operated around the clock with scheduled maintenance breaks of up to three hours per week, and any reprinting of the documents obtained required a mandatory reference to the "Kodeks" information system[14].

The contact details on the site were Kremlin ones: "603082, Nizhny Novgorod, Kremlin, Bldg. 1, Office 106," telephones (8312) 39-13-25 and 39-10-59, telephone/fax 39-10-59 and 39-16-07, e-mail address kw@inforis.ru[15].

Who was behind it

INFORIS was not merely the holder of a legal database. The enterprise's own pages — where it was called "GUP NTsTI" — listed three lines of business: internet access via dial-up and leased lines, telematic services (e-mail and hosting), and the "Kodeks" legal systems for accountants, lawyers, and builders, plus website development and internet advertising campaigns[16].

The node was a serious one for its time: an inbound modem pool of 28 lines supporting V.34+, with an Internet connection over a 256 Kbit/s digital channel to the node of the joint-stock company Delovaya Set in Moscow — the former Relcom, itself connected to the Net by a 34 Mbit/s channel[16]. The same page states what matters most for the history of the local network: "GUP NTsTI is the operator of the geographic domain NNOV and provides addresses in this domain free of charge"[16] — that is, the Nizhny Novgorod geographic zone was issued from the same node as the legal database.

The enterprise had held its licenses since the mid-1990s: No. 8912 of December 5, 1997 from the State Committee of the Russian Federation for Communications and Informatics, for data transmission services; No. 5012 of October 4, 1996 from the Ministry of Communications of the Russian Federation, for telematic services; and construction license No. 005188 of May 2, 1997, for the design and installation of computer networks[17]. A separate certificate gave it the right to distribute the "Kodeks" professional legal systems[18]. Among its awards, the page listed a letter of appreciation for information support of the exhibition "Nizhny Novgorod Region. The Road to the 21st Century," held on June 9–10, 1998 at the Federation Council, and its inclusion in 1999 in the list of the region's 45 leading business and financial structures, according to "Elite of Nizhny Novgorod Business"[19].

Its offices occupied two buildings of the Kremlin — Building 1, rooms 105–109, and Building 4, rooms 1–4; the director was Mikhail Markovich Konikov[1]. The copyright notice on the main page of laws.ru was brief: "© 1999 Internet Center 'INFORIS'"[3], and on the English version, "© 1999 Internet Center 'INFORIS'"[7]. The Internet center itself dated its work from 1994: that copyright appeared on its pages as early as 1997[20]. Later the provider also acquired a forum — Forum — Dialogue with the Provider".

How It Was Used

No direct evidence of traffic has survived, but the "Feedback" page has: exactly one letter, which arrived at kw@inforis.ru on November 11, 1999[21]:

It's now been two months that I (a lawyer) have been looking for the PRESIDENTIAL DECREE OF AUGUST 17, 1999, and today I finally found it — on your server. I also want to express my HUGE gratitude for the convenience of the interface.

— letter to the "Feedback" page, November 11, 1999

What Happened to the Address

By June 2002, judging by the description on the home page, the database had tripled in size — "over 140,000 documents in Russian and more than 1,300 in English," with the same search setup and the same Nizhny Novgorod caveat[4]. This is the last substantive version of the site: in January 2003 the address already responded with a redirect, and in June 2003 it served a server utility page — a list of man-pages manuals for the CRUX distribution, signed Powered by CRUX[22].

From 2004 the project's place was taken by a notice: "The domain LAWS.RU is for sale! For inquiries about purchasing the laws.ru domain, contact: nnov@ip-center.ru, tel/fax: (8312) 30-00-93, 30-99-69. © Internet company 'IP-Center', 2002-2004"[5]. In February 2005 the same page was still up at www.laws.ru[23].

IP-Center was not an outside firm that had bought an abandoned name, but the same team under a new sign. Its own "About the Company" page said: "The Internet company IP-Center (until October 2002 its old name was the design studio INFORIS) has worked in the internet advertising market since 1994. We created the first web site in Nizhny Novgorod"[24]. The domain ip-center.ru was registered on October 13, 2002[25] — exactly when, according to the page, the name changed. So the legal database's domain did not pass to strangers: it remained with INFORIS's web division, which by then was building corporate sites and running the www.nnov.ru portal, launched on January 30, 2002[26].

The most unexpected twist in the address's biography is tied to this portal. In January–March 2005 the web archive recorded at laws.ru (without www) not the for-sale notice but the pages of www.nnov.ru — "Nizhny Novgorod. A Site for Nizhny Novgorod Residents": regional news, banking news, an events calendar, a directory of Nizhny Novgorod sites, car sections with the emblems of GAZ, PAZ, ZMZ, and the Arzamas Machine-Building Plant, transport schedules, and forums[27]. In 2005 alone the web archive recorded more hits at this address than in all four years of the legal database's operation.

After that the address was occupied by placeholders. In October 2007 it showed a Russian Apache test page[28]; in the 2010s, domain-parking pages: in 2018, "laws.ru — This website is for sale!" on the Sedo marketplace[29], and later, hosting ads. No substantive site ever appeared on the domain again.

What remains of it

The web archive captured the address from November 1999, but all the substantive pages of the legal site itself date from 1999–2002: the home page, "Payment for Services," "What You Need to Work," "Free Content," "Testimonials," "Contacts," the contract, and two English pages — and that's all. The database itself is not in the archive and could not have been: the documents were served by a separate server requiring a login and password, and laws.ru was merely its storefront[3].

In the Nizhny Novgorod part of the story, this site stands alongside two other attempts to sell legal information through the web: news.api.nnov.ru — the site of the Nizhny Novgorod Legal Information Agency, a regional center of the ConsultantPlus network — and the legislation sections on the city portals. The city's other closed sites are collected in the index Archaeology of the Nizhny Novgorod internet, and what happens to their addresses after closure is examined in the study The Fate of the Domains of Closed Nizhny Novgorod Sites.

The domain inforis.ru, where it all began, was registered on October 21, 1996, and remains registered to this day[30]; laws.ru, set up on November 13, 1998, is also still alive as a registry entry[2] — without a website.

Sources

  1. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "INFORIS Center. Office Locations and Contacts," Web Archive snapshot of July 8, 2000 (archive)
  2. nic.ru — Domain information for laws.ru (whois)
  3. web.archive.org — Home page, "RUSSIAN LEGISLATION," Web Archive snapshot of November 22, 1999 (archive)
  4. web.archive.org — Home page, Web Archive snapshot of June 5, 2002 (archive)
  5. web.archive.org — "…for sale!", Web Archive snapshot of August 30, 2004 (archive)
  6. web.archive.org — black.inforis.nnov.su, "Inforis Databases," Web Archive snapshot of December 12, 1998 (archive)
  7. web.archive.org — "RUSSIAN LAWS," English version of the site, Web Archive snapshot of May 10, 2000 (archive)
  8. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "Legislation in the KODEKS Information Retrieval System," Web Archive snapshot of February 21, 1999 (archive)
  9. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "LAWS: KODEKS and INFOBASE. Data bases of Russian laws," Web Archive snapshot of February 18, 1999 (archive)
  10. web.archive.org — "Fees for Services," Web Archive snapshot of January 8, 2000 (archive)
  11. web.archive.org — "What You Need to Access the Kodeks Legislation Database over the Internet," Web Archive snapshot of January 8, 2000 (archive)
  12. web.archive.org — "Free of Charge," Web Archive snapshot of February 6, 2000 (archive)
  13. web.archive.org — "How to Subscribe," English-language subscription page, Web Archive snapshot of May 23, 2000 (archive)
  14. web.archive.org — "Information Services Agreement," Web Archive snapshot of January 8, 2000 (archive)
  15. web.archive.org — "Contacts," Web Archive snapshot of February 6, 2000 (archive)
  16. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "State Unitary Enterprise NTSI. Main Areas of Activity," Web Archive snapshot of September 30, 2000 (archive)
  17. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "State Unitary Enterprise NTSI. Licenses and Certificates," Web Archive snapshot of September 30, 2000 (archive)
  18. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "State Unitary Enterprise NTSI. Partner Authorizations," Web Archive snapshot of September 30, 2000 (archive)
  19. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "State Unitary Enterprise NTSI. Awards," Web Archive snapshot of September 30, 2000 (archive)
  20. web.archive.org — inforis.ru, "Welcome to the INFORIS Web Server," Web Archive snapshot of June 30, 1997 (archive)
  21. web.archive.org — "Testimonials," Web Archive snapshot of February 6, 2000 (archive)
  22. web.archive.org — Service page of the man-pages manuals of the CRUX distribution on the domain, Web Archive snapshot of June 3, 2003 (archive)
  23. web.archive.org — Domain sale notice on www.laws.ru, Web Archive snapshot of February 10, 2005 (archive)
  24. web.archive.org — ip-center.ru, "About the IP-Center Company," Web Archive snapshot of September 1, 2004 (archive)
  25. nic.ru — Domain information for ip-center.ru (whois)
  26. web.archive.org — ip-center.ru, studio news and announcement of the launch of the www.nnov.ru portal, Web Archive snapshot of November 22, 2002 (archive)
  27. web.archive.org — Pages of the www.nnov.ru portal at laws.ru, Web Archive snapshot of January 22, 2005 (archive)
  28. web.archive.org — "Test Page for Apache Installation" placeholder on the domain, Web Archive snapshot of October 19, 2007 (archive)
  29. web.archive.org — "This website is for sale!", Web Archive snapshot of January 1, 2018 (archive)
  30. nic.ru — Domain information for inforis.ru (whois)